Book Review: Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert

I picked up Big Magic in April 2020, a few weeks into lockdown, mostly to prove I didn’t need it. I’d read a small library’s worth of creativity books by then and was ~ certain ~ Elizabeth Gilbert had nothing new to tell me. I was wrong. Cheerfully, thoroughly wrong.

The spoiler-free premise (it’s nonfiction, but Gilbert tells so many stories it barely counts): a field guide to living creatively without fear running the show. Ideas, in Gilbert’s cosmology, are alive — they travel from person to person looking for someone willing to make them real, and your job is to say yes while your fear sulks in the back seat.

What I Loved About Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert

The chapter that stuck: her takedown of the suffering-artist myth. Gilbert argues the tortured-genius routine is destructive branding we’ve all inherited, and that playfulness — actual, unserious joy — produces better work than martyrdom ever has. I’ve said for years that the starving-artist myth was PR, and you were never the customer. Gilbert got there first and said it kinder. She also treats creativity as something healing rather than something that bleeds you, which landed hard in a season when the world felt like it was ending.

And then there’s the money chapter, which people assume argues with my entire career. It doesn’t. Gilbert’s advice is to never demand that your art pay your bills — keep your day job and protect the work from that pressure. Here’s the thing: I agree with her. My client writing pays the bills. My novels get to be pure play, no invoice attached. That division of labor is the least romantic and most useful creative decision I’ve ever made.

What I Didn’t Love About Big Magic

Honestly? Only that I waited five years to read it because I assumed I was above it. Consider that a warning.

Final Thoughts on Big Magic

A warm, funny, permission-granting read — the mental equivalent of a long walk with your least anxious friend. If you like your creativity books with more marching orders, my review of The War of Art covers the drill sergeant, and The Artist’s Way brings the structured program. Gilbert brings the picnic. And when the bill-paying half of your creative life needs an actual plan, that’s what I wrote Write for Money and Power for.

My final score: 5 out of 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Do I recommend this book? 👍 Yes — especially if your inner critic has tenure.

🔥 A Deadly Trials Romantasy on Kindle Unlimited: The Ash Trials

Saffron Vale wakes in a ruined wedding dress, locked in a prison for the kingdom’s deadliest criminals — with no memory of who she is.

To survive the brutal Ash Trials, she must outlast shifters, spellcasters, and something even more dangerous: the truth about herself. Her only allies? A traitorous commander from her past and an assassin who swears she’s the real monster here.

The truth could save her — or destroy everything.

Get the book now on Amazon and Kindle Unlimited: