Bones Bagels Review: Sourdough Bagels in Noe Valley

Bones Bagels is the green-walled bagel shop on Diamond Street in Noe Valley, with a chalk-line mural over the kitchen window, scalloped glass lamps, and a line of people waiting to order under them. It is on the short list my husband Kyle sends to anyone visiting San Francisco, so on a Saturday in August we got in that line.
Bones Bagels is a sourdough bagel shop at 741 Diamond St in San Francisco’s Noe Valley, and its open-face bagel sandwiches are great. The sourdough bagels underneath are really solid, and Kyle’s review, in his own words, is “amazing bagels with incredible ingredients.” He was right.
What to Order at Bones Bagels
We got the prosciutto bagel and the salmon sandwich ($18 each, both on everything bagels), plus a cookie for the road. Get both. They come open-face in a takeout clamshell, so each half gets its own full set of toppings. The salmon is the classic done carefully: a schmear, cucumber, lox, pickled red onion, capers, dill, and a slice of lemon. The prosciutto bagel stacks a schmear, arugula and folds of prosciutto, then finishes with chopped pecans and a dark, sticky drizzle.
Order the open-face sandwiches. They are the reason to come, and the bagel holds up to everything piled on it. One more tip from the same block: Diamond Cafe, a few doors down, was our brunch the weekend before, and we didn’t love it. If you’re choosing one breakfast on this stretch of Diamond Street, make it Bones.

The prosciutto bagel, under the Bones mural.
The Verdict on Bones Bagels
- Best for: A weekend bagel run in Noe Valley · open-face bagel sandwiches · anyone on Kyle’s visitor list
- Our order: The prosciutto bagel and the salmon sandwich, both on everything, plus a cookie
- Damage: $46 with tax and tip, for two
- Where: 741 Diamond St, Noe Valley (Google Maps)
For the rest of the city’s bagels, my best bagels in San Francisco guide has the classic and gluten-free picks, and my San Francisco page has the weekend list Bones now sits on.
For more places worth your appetite, my Los Angeles page pins my LA reviews on one map, and the best restaurants in San Francisco covers the other half of my eating life. Subscribe to my newsletter for new reviews as the research continues — I spent five years rating restaurants around the world in my travel guides, and old habits die delicious.
