Book Review: Creativity, Inc. by Ed Catmull

I’ve sat in a TV writers’ room where a draft someone loved gets taken apart before lunch, kindly and completely, and somehow the episode is better by dinner. Creativity, Inc. is the first book I’ve read that explains the machinery behind that trick: how you build a room where honesty makes the work better instead of smaller. Ed Catmull ran Pixar. He knows.

The premise: Catmull co-founded Pixar and spent decades as its president, and this is half memoir, half management manual — the production crises that nearly killed Toy Story, the invention of the Braintrust, and the systems Pixar built to protect new ideas from the corporate immune response. Technically it’s a business book. It reads like someone finally wrote down the house rules of every great creative room.

What I Loved About Creativity, Inc. by Ed Catmull

The Braintrust chapter is the best thing I’ve read about giving notes. The rules are simple and brutal: the feedback targets the work, never the person, and the room has no authority — the director doesn’t have to take a single suggestion. The good creative rooms I’ve been part of ran on a homemade version of this, and every room that breaks, breaks exactly where Catmull predicts: notes become verdicts, and people start protecting themselves instead of the story.

I also love his ‘ugly babies’ idea — that new ideas arrive awkward and easy to kill, and a leader’s real job is protecting them from premature judgment, including your own. I founded a literary collective once and ran the whole thing on instinct. I would have made fewer messes with this book on my desk.

What I Didn’t Love About Creativity, Inc.

The honest scope note: this is a book about leading creative people. If you’re a solo writer with no team and no plans for one, the middle chapters — org changes, meeting structures, the mechanics of running a studio — will read like minutes from someone else’s staff meeting. Skim them and stay for the philosophy. If you lead anyone at all, skip nothing.

Final Thoughts on Creativity, Inc.

A must-read if you run a creative organization or lead creative people, and a genuinely fun read even if you just love a good behind-the-scenes. It pairs perfectly with Orbiting the Giant Hairball: MacKenzie writes for the artist surviving the institution, Catmull writes for the person running it. Read both and you’ve seen the whole chessboard. (I eventually chose the smallest possible org chart — that story’s in my book.)

My final score: 5 out of 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Do I recommend this book? 👍 Yes — required if anyone reports to you, recommended even if no one does.

🔥 A Deadly Trials Romantasy on Kindle Unlimited: The Ash Trials

Saffron Vale wakes in a ruined wedding dress, locked in a prison for the kingdom’s deadliest criminals — with no memory of who she is.

To survive the brutal Ash Trials, she must outlast shifters, spellcasters, and something even more dangerous: the truth about herself. Her only allies? A traitorous commander from her past and an assassin who swears she’s the real monster here.

The truth could save her — or destroy everything.

Get the book now on Amazon and Kindle Unlimited: